This case involves a whistle-blower matter relating to a state statute against false claims of a large telecommunications company in West Virginia. This latest lawsuit was only the most recent of the cell companies’ legal troubles, however; they had already become embroiled in a privacy lawsuit which alleged that they had been allowing illegal phone recordings of their clients’ calls the be accessed by government agencies, throwing their public stock and customer trust into turmoil before the onset of this particular litigation. Within this new case, many state entities were part of a group contract negotiated by the state in which cell phone carries agreed they would provide the lowest cost service possible, optimizing cell service through faster connections using ‘soft switch’ software. This tends to result in significant cost savings for consumers, but it was alleged that the cell phone carries never optimized the cell service and thus never provided the lowest cost plans.